Best Across the Boards, According to Peer Votes (2023)

This table includes all plastic surgeons who were ranked by peers as being among “America’s Best Plastic Surgeons 2023” in all 5 of the 5 surgical procedures for which ratings were collected and published by Newsweek magazine:

This table is ordered by combined total ranking among the surveyed surgical procedures, placing the very highest-rated surgeons at the top, though all surgeons on this list were rated as among America’s best.

Plastic Surgeons Voted Best Across the Boards, in All 5 Surgical Subspecialties

#	Plastic Surgeon	Breast Augmentation Rank	Eyelid Surgery Rank	Liposuction Rank	Facelift Rank	Rhinoplasty Rank	Gender	Location
1	Rod J. Rohrich, MD	3	1	1	1	1	Male	Dallas, TX
2	Alan Matarasso, MD, FACS	11	6	2	7	6	Male	New York, NY
3	David Hidalgo, MD, FACS	2	17	7	15	29	Male	New York, NY
4	Garth Fisher, MD	5	12	9	20	31-165	Male	Beverly Hills, CA
5	James Zins, MD	31-175	5	24	9	12	Male	Beachwood, OH
6	Daniel C. Baker, MD	31-175	9	31-165	6	14	Male	New York, NY
7	Adam R. Kolker, MD, FACS	6	26	8	31-175	31-165	Male	New York, NY
8	Louis P. Bucky, MD, FACS	10	22	27	13	31-165	Male	Philadelphia, PA
9	Bill G. Kortesis, MD, FACS	13	31-125	10	31-175	22	Male	Charlotte, NC
10	Foad Nahai, MD, FACS	31-175	7	31-165	8	31-165	Male	Atlanta, Hiram, GA
11	Steven R. Cohen, MD, FACS	14	27	29	11	30	Male	San Diego, CA
12	Henry A. Mentz, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	12	10	Male	Houston, TX
13	Richard A. Bartlett, MD	31-175	31-125	15	27	13	Male	Brookline, MA
14	Marissa Tenenbaum, MD	8	31-125	25	31-175	23	Female	St. Louis, MO
15	Adam Schaffner, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	6	23	31-165	Male	New York, NY
16	Jay W. Calvert, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	3	Male	Beverly Hills, CA
17	Sanjay Grover, MD, FACS	9	31-125	26	31-175	31-165	Male	Newport Beach, CA
18	Jennifer L. Walden, MD	21	31-125	18	29	31-165	Female	Austin, TX
19	A. George Volpe, MD, FACS	31-175	10	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Boston, MA
20	Brian V. Heil, MD, FACS	17	31-125	31-165	31-175	27	Male	Pittsburgh, PA
21	Paul Stephen Cederna, MD	31-175	14	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Ann Arbor, MI
22	Jason Roostaeian, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	16	Male	Los Angeles, CA
23	Julius W. Few, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	17	31-165	Male	Chicago, IL
24	Terence M. Myckatyn, MD	31-175	31-125	21	31-175	31-165	Male	St. Louis, MO
25	Sumner A. Slavin, MD	22	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Chestnut Hill, MA
26	Steven M. Levine, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	24	31-165	Male	New York, NY
27	Ankit Desai, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	28	31-165	Male	Jacksonville, FL
28	Anthony Berlet, MD	31-175	28	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Cedar Grove, NJ
29	Peter G. Cordeiro, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	28	Male	Middletown, NY
30	Aaron Stone, MD	31-175	30	30	31-175	31-165	Male	Beverly Hills, CA
31	Andrew P. Giacobbe, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Williamsville, NY
32	Andrew Trussler, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Austin, TX
33	David Stoker, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Marina del Ray, CA
34	Enrique J. Armenta, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Syracuse, NY
35	Jane S. Weston, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Female	Menlo Park, CA
36	M. Mark Mofid, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	La Jolla, CA
37	Remus Repta, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Scottsdale, AZ
38	Scott A. Spiro, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	West Orange, NJ
39	Sheila Nazarian, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Female	Los Angeles, CA
40	Stephen Bresnick, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Encino, CA
41	Todd B. Koch, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Male	Williamsville , NY

Newsweek magazine’s survey results did not include surgeons’ genders; the Times includes the information above to aid patients in choosing a surgeon.

Female Plastic Surgeons Voted Best Across the Boards, in All 5 Surgical Subspecialties

#	Plastic Surgeon	Breast Augmentation Rank	Eyelid Surgery Rank	Liposuction Rank	Facelift Rank	Rhinoplasty Rank	Gender	Location
1	Marissa Tenenbaum, MD	8	31-125	25	31-175	23	Female	St. Louis, MO
2	Jennifer L. Walden, MD	21	31-125	18	29	31-165	Female	Austin, TX
3	Jane S. Weston, MD, FACS	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Female	Menlo Park, CA
4	Sheila Nazarian, MD	31-175	31-125	31-165	31-175	31-165	Female	Los Angeles, CA

Female plastic surgeons are also included in the table above, this subtable simply further highlights their achievement.

For more on women leading in aesthetic surgery, see “America’s Best Female Plastic Surgeons (2021)” and “35 Women Voted ‘America’s Best Plastic Surgeons’ [2022].”

Best Across the Boards, According to Peer Votes (2023)

Plastic Surgeons Voted Best Across the Boards, in All 5 Surgical Subspecialties

Female Plastic Surgeons Voted Best Across the Boards, in All 5 Surgical Subspecialties

More Stories

Pro Bono Botch Repair Brightens Patient’s Journey